• Skyp
  • Posts
  • How to Re-Engage Prospects Who Went Cold

How to Re-Engage Prospects Who Went Cold

Don’t let non-replies die. Reactivate with relevance—not spam.

Author

Alexander Shartsis
July 25, 2025

Silence isn’t a “no.”
It’s just… silence.

The inbox is messy.
Your prospect isn’t ignoring you because they hate your offer—they’re buried in 200 unread threads.

The mistake? Treating a cold lead like a dead one.

🛠️ The Reactivation Playbook: Waking Up Dormant Threads

✉️ 1. Don’t “Just Circle Back”

There’s nothing more robotic than:

“Just checking if you saw my last email.”

Instead, re-enter with relevance.

  • Point to a recent company change (hiring, funding, product launch).

  • Drop a new angle they haven’t seen before.

✅ Example:

“Noticed you’re hiring your first CS lead—has that shifted how you’re thinking about scaling renewals?”

🕊️ 2. Lower the Friction

Your original CTA might’ve been too heavy. Now make it feather-light.

✅ Example:

“Totally fine if now’s not the time—want me to send a 2-min teardown of how others solved this?”

No pressure. Just momentum.

📝 3. Acknowledge the Silence

Show them you’re human—not automation.

✅ Example:

“Realize my timing might’ve been off last time. Should I circle back next quarter, or is this no longer a focus?”

This reframes the conversation without guilt or pushiness.

🚀 4. Add Micro-Value

Wake them up with something worth engaging on:

  • A fresh insight about their space

  • A short case study

  • A quick-win tactic

✅ Example:

“We just published a teardown of how 3 Series A teams doubled reply rates. Want me to send it over?”

⚡ Pro Tip: Build a Reactivation Rhythm

  • Keep a simple “cold list” (3+ touches, no reply)

  • Set a 6–8 week re-engagement cadence

  • Rotate 2–3 reactivation assets so your emails never feel stale

Cold isn’t dead.
It’s just dormant.

Show up with:
✅ Fresh context
✅ A lighter ask
✅ A reason to care

…and you’ll turn forgotten leads into real conversations.

Because silence isn’t rejection—it’s an invitation to try again.

And if this is the kind of outbound you want to get better at—not just spraying templates, but writing emails that actually bring cold leads back to life—you’ll want to catch this LIVE session we’re hosting:

“The 10 Email Secrets Top Founders Use to Triple Their Response Rates”
with Gregory Kennedy and Alexander Shartsis.

🗓️ July 30 | 9:00–10:30 AM PST
📍 Save your spot here →

It’s free. It’s tactical. It’ll probably change how you do cold email.